Terrashollander op drift

[Dr. Marc-Alexander Fluks]

REPLY TO: D66 at nic.surfnet.nl

[This sluit perfect aan op mijn '10 stellingen' over het nihilisme van Tweede
 Pinksterdag, https://listserv.surfnet.nl/scripts/WA.EXE?A2=ind0606&L=d66&X=&P=R12681 ]

Bron:  The American Thinker
Datum: 7 juni 2006
URL:   http://www.americanthinker.com/articles.php?article_id=5558


The Dutch Adrift
----------------
Alvino-Mario Fantini

AMSTERDAM - For the past semester, I've lived above one of this city's notorious
hash-and-marijuana coffee shops, on a corner in the this city's famed Red Light
district. Legalized drugs and prostitution are generally what Americans think of
when they think of Amsterdam, but I can assure you that after a while, its
salaciousness begins to seem quite boring. Really. And what becomes apparent,
when the sensational has lost even its entertainment value, is that Holland is
in a deep crisis.

Despite what you may hear these days about the Netherlands, it wasn't always a
European center of sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll. Although a kind of libertarian
humanism, typified by Erasmus of Rotterdam, does seem to have characterized
Dutch society for centuries, it wasn't quite the secular humanism of today.

The full-throttle and state-sanctioned hedonism of twenty-first century Holland
finds no inspiration or legitimacy in any of the centuries preceding the
twentieth. In short, Dutch society used to have - dare I say it - a more
religious foundation on which the values of humanism, intellectual openness and
tolerance were based.

I think it can be argued that this departure from this past - and the virtual
rooting out of Holland]s rich Christian humanism - as contributed directly to
the rise of the culturally confused, politically feeble, guilt-ridden and
self-negating Dutch of today. One might even suggest that the modern history of
Holland is the history of Europe, writ small.

I moved to Holland in January to take graduate courses in journalism and
politics. In my free time, I have scoured different libraries and bookstores,
looking for anything that might tell me what Dutch society may have been like
before today's hookers and hookahs. I also tried to talk to different Dutch
people, especially those who, according to my reasoning, offered the best
glimpse into Holland's past - those who came of age before the counter-cultural
revolution of the 1960s.

Historians explain that until the tumult of the 1960s, Dutch society used to be
structured into four separate, tightly organized ideological 'columns' (or
pillars) - Catholic, Protestant, Socialist and a laissez-faire or classically
liberal one. Each column had its own infrastructure - that is, its own
neighborhoods, industries, newspapers and institutions. Lacking a 'neutral
public sector', Dutch people relied primarily on their families within each
column for identity and support.

The Catholic column is of special interest since sociologists tell us that until
the 1960s, the Dutch Catholic Church was the most traditional on the European
continent. You'd certainly never guess that today. A local priest, well past
retirement, told me one day that most cradle-Catholics in Holland, even those
with traditionalist inclinations, simply allowed themselves to be carried away
by the broader societal changes during the 1960s. 'They weren't so much tolerant
[of the changes] as they were completely indifferent,' he explained.

Holland still observes national religious holidays. But talk to a few locals and
you'll quickly see how for the vast majority of citizens these now are devoid of
any real spiritual content. Easter and Pentecost are no more than tattered
remnants of a common patrimony that Holland formerly shared with other European
countries.

Among university students, little cognizance of the Kingdom of the Netherlands
as anything other than a rapacious former colonial oppressor is evident. They
are unaware of any former national greatness, and seem almost guilt-ridden by
their history. (I prefer to think of Holland as a formerly powerful maritime
republic, which had an enviable empire reaching across the globe, much of which
was brought under the civilizing yoke of the West through the United East India
Company.) In fact, Dutch students today show little more than a superficial
respect towards the artifacts of culture around them - churches, mansions,
museums - and seem to spend plenty of money, instead, on drinking and clubbing,
all-night raves, techno-parties and orgiastic revelry. They exhibit the very
same condition that afflicts the rest of Europe - in Jeffrey Hart's words, the
'draining away of seriousness, intensity, gravity, self-definition.'

If I were to be polemical, I would say that Holland has been in the throes of a
macabre death dance since the 1960s. But if I aim to be simply descriptive, I
would say that Dutch society has adopted nihilism as a philosophy of life - and
nihilism can never serve as a bulwark against civilizational challenges.

Whether one looks at the superficial expressions of Holland's rootlessness (the
legalized drugs and prostitution), or the government's failed multicultural
policies, or the 'targeted jihad' that brought an end to the lives of filmmaker
Theo van Gogh and politician Pim Fortuyn - or the cold, Calvinist approach to
immigration that recently forced the Immigration Ministry to revoke the
citizenship of Somali-born Dutch MP Aayan Hirsi Ali (who will now join the
American Enterprise Institute) - it;s clear that something is terribly amiss in
the Dutch soul.

I have to be careful here not to sound like I am blowing the trumpet for some
kind of spiritual revival. Not at all. I am simply rattling the saber for a
renewed recognition of Holland's - that is, Europe's - heritage of Greek reason
and Roman law. My diagnosis of Holland is entirely from a non-denominational,
civilizational point of view.

Sadly, Holland's current aimlessness, its society's loss of roots, the
relativism that guides its academic elites and its generally feckless political
class have made it incapable of any real assertion of national self or any
meaningful defense of beliefs. The national identity has been hollowed out over
the years; traditional Dutch beliefs have been forsaken;  and the past has been
extirpated. Nihilism of this sort, regardless of the number of tulips that
garland it, is an insufficient foundation on which to base liberal, democratic
values or a vibrant, civil society.


Alvino-Mario Fantini is currently an Erasmus Mundus scholar through the European
Union. He has previous written about Bolivia for The American Thinker.

--------
(c) 2006 The American Thinker

**********
Dit bericht is verzonden via de informele D66 discussielijst (D66 at nic.surfnet.nl).
Aanmelden: stuur een email naar LISTSERV at nic.surfnet.nl met in het tekstveld alleen: SUBSCRIBE D66 uwvoornaam uwachternaam
Afmelden: stuur een email naar LISTSERV at nic.surfnet.nl met in het tekstveld alleen: SIGNOFF D66
Het on-line archief is te vinden op: http://listserv.surfnet.nl/archives/d66.html
**********